Paige DeSorbo Confronts Craig Conover’s Claims: Reality TV Relationship Drama Unfolds

The Reality TV Breakup That Has Everyone Talking

Bravo fans have been following the dramatic aftermath of Paige DeSorbo and Craig Conover’s split with rapt attention. The reality TV stars, whose relationship played out across Summer House and Southern Charm, have been sharing conflicting accounts of their November 2024 breakup. Now, Paige DeSorbo is stepping forward to set the record straight after Craig Conover made several claims about their relationship ending that she says simply aren’t true.

The breakup, which was only made public over a month after it happened when Paige finally broke the news, has sparked intense speculation among fans. With both parties appearing on talk shows and their respective reality series, the narrative has become increasingly complicated as each presents their version of events.

Paige DeSorbo’s Side: Debunking Craig Conover’s Claims

During a recent appearance on Andy Cohen’s Watch What Happens Live, Paige DeSorbo didn’t hold back when asked about Craig Conover’s statements at the Southern Charm Reunion. When Cohen inquired about Craig’s various claims, Paige responded she disagreed with “all of it,” adding with a shade of sarcasm: “I loved listening to it because I was like, ‘What a fun story.'”

One particularly contentious claim involved Craig’s assertion that Paige had “considered marrying” him during BravoCon. Paige immediately shot this down with her characteristic wit: “Andy. Andy. Do I look like the kind of person that has the phrase ‘convention center’ in her wedding invitation?” This quip resonated with viewers, who have come to appreciate Paige’s fashion-forward image and sophisticated taste.

Paige’s Summer House co-star Kyle Cooke has publicly called Craig a “liar,” a sentiment with which Paige readily agreed, saying Kyle “nailed it.” This alliance with her castmate suggests a larger division between the Summer House and Southern Charm crews in the wake of the breakup, potentially setting up future tension across the Bravo universe.

Seemingly out of his element, Craig Conover doesn’t seem to be a happy camper during portions of ‘Summer House’ Season 9. (Image Credit: Bravo)

Inside the Breakup: What Really Happened

The November 2024 split between Paige and Craig initially generated confusion among fans, especially as the news only came to light in December when Paige finally shared it publicly. Craig has maintained that the “breakup was not a mutual decision,” a point on which Paige actually agrees—but with a significant twist in how she interprets his motivation for emphasizing this fact.

According to Paige, Craig’s repeated mentions of the breakup being non-mutual serve a particular purpose: “I felt like he was saying that because he wanted [to be] the victim,” she explained on WWHL. “He wanted people to be like, ‘She did it. She caused this.'” This characterization suggests Paige believes Craig is attempting to control the public narrative around their split.

Adding to the complexity were unsubstantiated cheating rumors that circulated after the breakup announcement. Paige expressed frustration that Craig seemed to “lean into” these rumors rather than denying them outright, potentially allowing speculation to damage her reputation in the Bravo community.

During the ‘Summer House’ Season 9 supertease, Paige DeSorbo tearfully predicts the end of her relationship. (Image Credit: Bravo)

The Aftermath: Moving On and Dating Lives

Both reality stars appear to be moving forward with their lives post-breakup. Craig has begun dating Natalie Buffett, a development about which Paige expressed support: “I love it,” she commented. “I’m so happy for him.” This gracious response suggests Paige has made peace with the end of their relationship, at least publicly.

As for her own romantic life, Paige confirmed she has “absolutely” been “dating people” and is “having a very good time.” However, she clarified to Andy Cohen that she isn’t currently in “anything serious.” With characteristic humor, she shared that her primary goal for her next relationship is to not be “the funny one” this time—a comment that might contain a subtle dig at her dynamic with Craig.

The transition from a high-profile relationship back to single life while in the public eye presents unique challenges, especially for reality TV personalities whose dating lives are often fodder for both on-screen storylines and off-screen gossip. Both Paige and Craig must navigate this terrain while filming their respective shows and maintaining their personal brands.

On a February 2025 episode of Watch What Happens Live, Craig Conover makes his feelings clear about his breakup. (Image Credit: Bravo)

Reality TV Drama: Summer House and Southern Charm Collide

The Paige-Craig saga represents a fascinating intersection of two major Bravo franchises: Summer House, where Paige is a main cast member, and Southern Charm, which features Craig. Their relationship initially delighted fans as a cross-show romance, but its dissolution has created ripple effects throughout both casts.

Current episodes of Summer House Season 9 show early signs of trouble in their relationship, with Paige tearfully predicting its end in promotional material. Meanwhile, the Southern Charm Reunion featured Craig’s perspective on the breakup, setting up a “he said, she said” situation that viewers can follow across multiple shows.

This drama exemplifies the unique ecosystem of Bravo reality programming, where relationships form and dissolve not just on a single show but across an interconnected universe of series. Producers have skillfully used this breakup to generate interest in both shows, with viewers tuning in to see how each party is handling the split in their respective environments.

Looking Forward: What’s Next for Paige and Craig

As both reality stars move forward with their lives and careers, fans will undoubtedly continue to follow their journeys with interest. For Paige, her fashion career and continued presence on Summer House provide ample opportunities for professional growth beyond this relationship drama. Her candid and witty responses on WWHL demonstrate her ability to navigate public scrutiny with grace and humor.

Craig, meanwhile, continues to develop his pillow business, Sewing Down South, while remaining a central figure on Southern Charm. His new relationship with Natalie Buffett may feature in upcoming seasons, potentially offering viewers insight into how he’s evolved since his time with Paige.

The ex-couple will likely continue to cross paths in the Bravo universe, particularly at events like BravoCon where stars from various shows come together. How they manage these interactions, and whether they can eventually establish a friendly post-romantic relationship, remains to be seen.

What’s clear is that both Paige DeSorbo and Craig Conover understand the value of controlling their own narratives in the court of public opinion. As Paige’s recent WWHL appearance demonstrates, she’s unwilling to let Craig’s version of events stand unchallenged—ensuring that fans will continue to receive new perspectives on this reality TV breakup saga for seasons to come.