Donald Trump Says He's Bringing Back Columbus Day After Dems Destroyed 'Reputation'
Trump Columbus Day Policy: Former President Promises to Restore Holiday “From the Ashes”
Former President Donald Trump has announced a new Trump Columbus Day Policy initiative, vowing to fight against what he describes as the Left’s destruction of Christopher Columbus’s reputation. In a passionate Truth Social post, Trump declared his intention to bring Columbus Day “back from the ashes,” positioning himself as a defender of Italian American heritage and traditional American celebrations.
Donald Trump shared his new Columbus Day policy on Truth Social, pledging to restore the holiday to its former status and honor Italian Americans. (Photo: Getty Images)
Table of Contents
Trump’s Columbus Day Policy Announcement
The Trump Columbus Day Policy was unveiled through a series of posts on Truth Social, where the former president accused Democrats of systematically working to “destroy Christopher Columbus, his reputation, and all of the Italians that love him so much.” This announcement represents Trump’s latest foray into cultural politics, positioning himself as a defender of traditional American celebrations and Italian American heritage.
In his statement outlining the Trump Columbus Day Policy, the former president promised to reinstate Columbus Day “under the same rules, dates, and locations, as it has had for all of the many decades before!” The announcement appears designed to appeal to voters concerned about changing cultural norms and the reexamination of historical figures in American history.
While light on specific implementation details, the Trump Columbus Day Policy signifies an intention to push back against the movement to replace or rename Columbus Day celebrations with Indigenous Peoples’ Day observances. This stance aligns with Trump’s broader criticism of what he frequently refers to as “woke culture” and attempts to revise historical narratives.
Key Elements of the Trump Columbus Day Policy
While specifics remain limited, Trump’s announcement suggests several positions:
- Opposition to the renaming of Columbus Day as Indigenous Peoples’ Day
- Support for restoring and protecting Columbus statues and monuments
- Framing the debate as defending Italian American heritage
- Suggesting federal power would be used to maintain Columbus Day traditions
- Positioning the issue as part of a broader cultural conflict
Context: Columbus Statues and Cultural Debates
The Trump Columbus Day Policy announcement references the removal of Columbus statues that occurred in various cities, particularly following the racial justice protests after George Floyd’s murder in 2020. During this period, numerous Columbus monuments were either officially removed by local governments or toppled by protesters who viewed them as symbols of colonialism and oppression.
In his Truth Social post, Trump specifically mentioned these statue removals, claiming that “a whole lotta woke statues went up in their place.” This characterization frames the Trump Columbus Day Policy as a response to what he perceives as the erasure of traditional American historical figures and their replacement with more contemporary or progressive alternatives.
The debate over Columbus statues and imagery represents a broader cultural conversation about how America commemorates its history. Critics of Columbus point to well-documented historical accounts of exploitation and violence toward indigenous peoples, while supporters emphasize his role in European exploration and his symbolic importance to Italian Americans—a nuance that the Trump Columbus Day Policy clearly sides with.
Current Status of Columbus Day as a Federal Holiday
A critical context for understanding the Trump Columbus Day Policy is the fact that Columbus Day remains an official federal holiday in the United States, observed on the second Monday in October. Despite Trump’s framing that suggests the holiday needs to be “brought back,” Columbus Day has never been removed from the federal calendar of official holidays.
What has changed, however, is how the holiday is observed across different jurisdictions. Many states and localities have chosen to rename or dual-designate the day as Indigenous Peoples’ Day, a trend that has accelerated in recent years. This local-level shift appears to be the primary target of the Trump Columbus Day Policy, rather than any actual change at the federal level.
The discrepancy between Trump’s characterization of Columbus Day as needing restoration and its continued status as a federal holiday raises questions about what specific actions a Trump Columbus Day Policy would actually entail. The announcement may be more symbolic than substantive, aimed at energizing supporters who perceive traditional American celebrations as under threat.
| Level of Government | Current Columbus Day Status | Indigenous Peoples’ Day Status |
|---|---|---|
| Federal Government | Official federal holiday | Acknowledged by Biden administration, not a federal holiday |
| States (varies by state) | Observed in most states | Officially replaced Columbus Day in 18 states |
| Major Cities | Varies by municipality | Recognized in over 130 cities |
| School Districts | Still observed in many districts | Increasingly observed instead of Columbus Day |
| Private Sector | Observed by some employers | Growing recognition in corporations |
The Italian American Connection
A significant aspect of the Trump Columbus Day Policy is its framing as a defense of Italian American heritage and identity. In his announcement, Trump specifically mentioned “all of the Italians that love him [Columbus] so much,” directly linking the explorer’s legacy to Italian American cultural pride. This association has deep historical roots in the United States.
Columbus Day was first officially recognized as a federal holiday in 1937, following decades of advocacy by Italian American organizations. For many Italian Americans, particularly those whose families immigrated in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, Columbus represented a source of pride and legitimacy at a time when Italian immigrants faced significant discrimination and marginalization in American society.
By emphasizing this connection, the Trump Columbus Day Policy appears designed to resonate with Italian American voters, particularly in key electoral states with significant Italian American populations like New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, and Ohio. This appeal to ethnic identity and cultural heritage aligns with Trump’s broader political strategy of mobilizing specific demographic groups through cultural issues.
The Historical Context of Columbus Day for Italian Americans
The relationship between Columbus Day and Italian American identity has deep historical roots:
- The first recorded celebration of Columbus Day was organized by Italian immigrants in New York City in 1866
- President Benjamin Harrison called for a national observance in 1892, in part to ease tensions after the lynching of 11 Italian Americans in New Orleans
- The Knights of Columbus, a Catholic fraternal organization with Italian American roots, strongly advocated for the holiday
- FDR officially designated Columbus Day a federal holiday in 1937, following lobbying by Italian American organizations
- For many Italian Americans, Columbus represented acceptance into American society when they faced discrimination
Indigenous Peoples’ Day Perspective
While the Trump Columbus Day Policy emphasizes the importance of Columbus to Italian American heritage, it does not address the primary reason many jurisdictions have moved away from celebrating Columbus Day: the growing recognition of the devastating impact of European colonization on indigenous populations. This perspective is central to understanding the full context of the debate.
Indigenous Peoples’ Day was proposed as an alternative to Columbus Day at an international conference on discrimination sponsored by the United Nations in 1977. The city of Berkeley, California, became the first U.S. jurisdiction to officially replace Columbus Day with Indigenous Peoples’ Day in 1992, coinciding with the 500th anniversary of Columbus’s arrival in the Americas.
Historical records document that Columbus’s arrival led to the exploitation, enslavement, and death of millions of indigenous people across the Americas. For many Native Americans and their allies, celebrating Columbus Day is seen as honoring a figure who initiated centuries of genocide, disease, land theft, and cultural destruction—issues not addressed in Trump’s Columbus Day Policy announcement.
Indigenous Peoples’ Day: A Different Perspective
The movement to replace Columbus Day with Indigenous Peoples’ Day is based on several key points:
- Recognition of the estimated 55-90 million indigenous people who died following European contact
- Acknowledgment of Columbus’s documented mistreatment of indigenous peoples, including enslavement
- Opportunity to celebrate indigenous cultures and contributions rather than European colonization
- Educational focus on a more complete telling of American history
- Respect for the continuing presence and sovereignty of Native American nations
Practical Implications of Trump’s Columbus Day Policy
Given that Columbus Day remains a federal holiday, the practical implications of the Trump Columbus Day Policy are somewhat unclear. Since most changes to Columbus Day observances have occurred at state and local levels, federal action would have limited direct impact unless it involved unprecedented federal intervention in local holiday decisions.
Possible implementations of a Trump Columbus Day Policy might include executive orders requiring federal agencies to exclusively use the term “Columbus Day” rather than “Indigenous Peoples’ Day” in official communications, directing the National Park Service to maintain or restore Columbus monuments on federal land, or withholding certain federal funds from states or municipalities that have officially replaced Columbus Day.
However, the announcement may serve primarily as a campaign messaging strategy rather than a concrete policy proposal. By framing himself as a defender of Columbus Day, Trump positions himself on one side of an emotionally resonant cultural debate—a tactic that has proven effective in mobilizing certain voter demographics in previous campaigns.
Potential Federal Actions Under a Trump Columbus Day Policy
While specifics remain unclear, several potential federal actions could align with Trump’s announcement:
- Executive orders mandating federal agencies exclusively use “Columbus Day” terminology
- Directing federal funding toward restoration or protection of Columbus monuments
- Federal grant preferences for schools and institutions that observe Columbus Day
- Public celebration and ceremonial enhancement of Columbus Day at federal buildings
- Presidential proclamations emphasizing Columbus’s historical significance
Published on April 27, 2025 | Updated on April 28, 2025
About The Author
